Lever Talent Blog

The Adoption Illusion: 97% Use AI, and 28% See Extreme Value

Written by Drew Fortin | Nov 19, 2026, 11:50:44 PM

AI adoption in the mid-market is close to universal, most of those companies can’t yet point to extreme value from it, and they plan to spend more on it anyway. That combination is one of the five findings in The Co-Intelligent Workforce Report: 2026 Baseline.

97% of the companies we surveyed use at least one type of AI tool, and 92% will spend more on AI next year than they did this year. Only 28% say AI is extremely valuable to their business today. We call that gap “the Adoption Illusion,” and judged by value, the AI transformation in the mid-market has barely started.


Chart 1.1 from the Co-Intelligent Workforce Report

We surveyed 484 Director-and-above leaders at US and Canadian companies with 100 to 999 employees in August and September 2026, with research strategy by Port Research and survey design and fielding by Researchscape. “Extremely valuable” is the top answer on a five-point scale, so the 28% counts only the companies that gave AI the highest rating available. The value question went to a random half of respondents.

Why AI ROI lags AI adoption

Here’s my read on the economics. AI itself has reached commodity status. Every one of your competitors can buy the same models you can, at the same price, today, and nothing that everyone has can be a lasting advantage on its own. When 97% of a market has bought something, the purchase stops telling you much about which companies are going to pull ahead.

The pattern I see most often in our client work goes like this. A company starts using AI with real conviction, people experiment, and a few workflows seem to get faster. Then the momentum stalls, the executive team can’t say what the AI spend is returning, and the whole effort shrinks into a tool that drafts emails. Nobody ever decided what AI was for, who owned it, or how people and AI would divide the work.

Our report says it in one line: most companies have treated buying AI as if it were the same thing as becoming a business that runs well with AI. Liz Wilke, Chief Economist at LinkedIn, put the same problem in economic terms in her reaction in the report:

“AI compute is raw material. Turning it into valuable output requires intentional structure. These findings underscore the role that businesses’ process, and clarity of roles and ownership play in determining the economic returns on their AI inputs.”

Wilke’s raw material behaves like steel on a factory floor. A manufacturer that buys more of it without changing what it builds ends up with more inventory, and with 92% of companies raising AI spend in the year ahead, a lot of mid-market budgets risk heading that way in 2027.

What the rest of the research says

The same gap shows up among CEOs worldwide. PwC’s 29th Global CEO Survey, which drew on 4,454 CEOs in 95 countries and territories and was published in January, found that 56% of CEOs say they have seen no significant financial benefit from AI to date. Only 12% say AI has delivered both cost and revenue benefits. The CEOs in that 12% were two to three times as likely to say they have embedded AI extensively across their products and services, demand generation, and strategic decision-making.

McKinsey looked at the split from the employee side. Its July McKinsey Quarterly article, “From adoption to impact: Three horizons of AI transformation,” surveyed 750 employees across job levels earlier this year. 70% said they feel personally prepared to adopt and use AI. Among leaders, 27% said their organizations are ready to make the shifts McKinsey describes as necessary for an agentic future. The authors conclude that AI does not create enterprise value simply because more people use it, and their data shows leaders were 5.3 times as likely to report capturing enterprise value when workflows had been redesigned (32% compared with 6%). McKinsey cautions that its sample leaned toward organizations further along with AI, so its figures may not reflect the wider market.

Workers are adopting AI quickly. PwC’s Global Workforce Hopes and Fears Survey 2026, published in September from responses by 49,364 workers in 48 countries and regions, found that 64% of workers used AI at work in the past year, a ten-point jump, and daily use of generative AI rose from 14% to 22%. PwC’s recommendation to leaders is to redesign roles, workflows, and incentives to capture a return on that use.

From co-intelligence to co-intelligent teams

Wharton professor Ethan Mollick introduced the idea of co-intelligence in his 2024 book, Co-Intelligence: Living and Working with AI, which frames AI as a collaborative resource for the people who use it. We built on his concept for the title of our report because it describes what the companies getting real value from AI have built. A co-intelligent team is one where people and AI agents share the work on purpose, and someone has decided how that work is divided.

Getting from adoption to value is the work of what I call Workforce Orchestration™. It starts with understanding the capabilities you need across your technology, your programs, and your people. It means moving from everyone experimenting alone to a coordinated effort with an accountable owner, and it means keeping an account of the human and AI resources you’ve deployed and what each one is returning. The person accountable for that work is the Workforce Orchestrator™.

What HR leaders should do

  1. Put a value question next to every adoption metric. If your AI dashboard reports logins, seats, or prompts, add the question our survey asked: “Overall, how valuable is AI to your company currently?” In our research, that question is what surfaced the 28%.

  2. Collect specific examples of how AI has changed each team’s work. PwC’s data shows daily generative AI use climbing from 14% to 22% of workers in a year. Gather examples, team by team, of the tasks people now hand to AI every day, because those examples are the raw input for redesigning roles.

  3. Bring the readiness gap to the executive team. McKinsey’s split between 70% personal readiness and 27% organizational readiness belongs on the executive agenda, and HR runs the employee surveys that can measure it. Ask both questions inside your own company and present the difference as a business risk with a number attached.

  4. Tie every AI training program to one redesigned workflow. McKinsey found leaders were 5.3 times as likely to report capturing enterprise value when workflows had been redesigned. Pair each training program with one workflow the team will redesign while they learn, so the skill and the change land together.

What business executives should do

  1. Require a value hypothesis for every AI line in the 2027 budget. Before you approve more spend, ask each owner what the AI will change in the business, how you’ll measure it, and by when. With 92% of companies raising AI spend, the budget review is the moment to ask what each line has returned so far.

  2. Ask your leadership team to rate AI’s value on the same five-point scale. If your executives can’t agree on whether AI is extremely valuable or only somewhat valuable to the business, you’ve found your gap before spending another dollar.

  3. Fund integration and redesign alongside the licenses. PwC found that CEOs seeing both cost and revenue benefits were two to three times as likely to say they have embedded AI extensively across their products, demand generation, and strategic decisions. That work takes budget and leadership time, and it rarely shows up on a software invoice.

  4. Name one person accountable for how people and AI work together. Naming that owner is the first of the report’s five moves for the CEO. Someone has to own the decisions that turn adoption into value across every function, and that is the job of a Workforce Orchestrator.

Adoption is table stakes. The 28% is where the report starts. The full Co-Intelligent Workforce Report: 2026 Baseline shows what the companies getting extreme value from AI did differently, and it closes with five moves for the CEO and six for the head of HR. Download the full report here.